Profits and Kings
Chapter 6 - Night Scenes
by Dirk Anderson
Halfway through its chapter on Mount Carmel, Prophets and Kings does something odd. It stops telling the story in the past tense and slips into the present. “The priests gather about their altar.” “The morning passes, noon comes.” “Elijah watches every movement.” “No sooner is the prayer of Elijah ended than flames of fire, like brilliant flashes of lightning, descend from heaven.”1 For several pages the reader stands on the mountain with Elijah, watching it unfold.
It is a powerful effect. Was Ellen White reporting the vivid scenes she had personally witnessed in vision? Not exactly. Fifty years before Prophets and Kings, an American minister named Daniel March told the same story in the same breathless present tense: “No sooner has he spoken than the rushing flame descends from the clear heavens like the lightning's flash.”2 His book was called Night Scenes in the Bible. Readers of Patriarchs and Profits have met it before. It supplied Ellen White with vivid scenes from Genesis and Exodus. In Prophets and Kings it does the same for Elijah, for Jeremiah, and for the last night of Babylon.
A Book She Requested
Daniel March (1816–1909) was a popular American preacher and author whose Night Scenes in the Bible (1869) retold great biblical events that happened after dark, including Elijah in the cave and Belshazzar's feast. March wrote for the heart. His scenes are crowded with sound and color, his villains are lurid, his heroes are calm, and he never lets a moral lesson go unstated. The popular book sold well.
Ellen White owned it, and she wanted it close at hand. In 1878 she wrote to Mary White, her daughter-in-law: “Send books, red-covered Jewish Antiquities and the Bible Dictionary. Is Night Scenes of the Bible there? If so, send it.”3 Not surprisingly, these three sources show up repeatedly in her Conflict of the Ages series. White's copy of March's book later found a home in her office library, where her literary assistants worked.4
Walter Rea pointed to March's influence on Prophets and Kings more than forty years ago, listing the pages of March he believed lay behind the book.5 The plagiarism detection software used for this book confirms his core findings for the Elijah and Belshazzar chapters, pins them down passage by passage, and adds a chapter Rea did not list.
The Showdown on Carmel
March's account of Carmel is the heart of his Elijah chapter, and it is the heart of the copying. Start with the priests of Baal, dancing and cutting themselves around their altar while Elijah watches:
| March, Night Scenes in the Bible (1869) | Prophets and Kings (1917) |
|---|---|
| It is past midday, and still, hoping to gain time and find some device or sleight of hand by which the fire can be kindled, they continue their cries, cutting their flesh … staining their faces and their garments with their blood … mingling curses with their prayers to their pitiless sun-god … All the while Elijah stands alone, waiting and knowing full well that if by any deceit or cunning they should kindle the altar the people will join with them in tearing him in pieces.6 | The crafty priests are continually trying to devise some means by which they may kindle a fire upon the altar … hoping against hope … continue to carry on their senseless ceremonies. … their garments stained with blood from self-inflicted wounds … they now mingle with their pleading terrible cursings of their sun-god, and Elijah continues to watch intently; for he knows that if by any device the priests should succeed in kindling their altar fire, he would instantly be torn in pieces.7 |
The Bible says that the priests cried out and cut themselves until the blood gushed out. It does not say that they were secretly trying to light their own fire, or that Elijah watched them because he knew he would be torn apart if they managed it, or that they cursed their “sun-god.” Those are March's additions, and all of them reappear in Prophets and Kings.
Then comes the contrast between the frenzied priests and the calm prophet, and then the fire:
| March (1869) | Prophets and Kings (1917) |
|---|---|
| The maddened priests of Baal … exhausted with their own frenzy … With calm and solemn deportment, Elijah rebuilds the altar … The great multitude are pale and breathless with awful expectation … His calm and simple prayer and his peaceful deportment are more impressive than the foaming fury and the wild cries of a thousand priests of Baal.8 | The disappointed priests of Baal, exhausted by their vain efforts, wait to see what Elijah will do. … The people, fearful also, and almost breathless with expectancy, watch while Elijah continues his preparations. The calm demeanor of the prophet stands out in sharp contrast with the fanatical, senseless frenzy of the followers of Baal.9 |
| No sooner has he spoken than the rushing flame descends from the clear heavens like the lightning's flash, and the very stones of the altar are burnt up with the devouring fire. The sudden blaze blinds the eyes of the multitude and illumines the whole slope of the mountain … The people watching afar off, on the house-tops in Jezreel and Samaria … are startled at the sight. It seems to them as if the pillar of fire that led their fathers in the desert had descended upon Carmel.10 | No sooner is the prayer of Elijah ended than flames of fire, like brilliant flashes of lightning, descend from heaven upon the upreared altar … consuming even the stones of the altar. The brilliancy of the blaze illumines the mountain and dazzles the eyes of the multitude. In the valleys below, where many are watching … the descent of fire is clearly seen, and all are amazed at the sight. It resembles the pillar of fire which at the Red Sea separated the children of Israel from the Egyptian host.11 |
Here the dependence is unmistakable. The order of ideas is the same: the fire falls like lightning, consumes the stones, lights up the mountain, blinds the crowd, is seen by distant watchers, and reminds them of the pillar of fire. Beyond the fire itself and what it consumed, none of this sequence is in 1 Kings 18. March imagined it; Prophets and Kings repeats it.
The King and His Servant
March was fascinated by the reversal of power between Ahab and Elijah: the king who had hunted the prophet for three years suddenly obeying him like a servant. Prophets and Kings took the idea and much of the wording, twice:
| March (1869) | Prophets and Kings (1917) |
|---|---|
| The passionate king is so awed and unmanned by the presence of the prophet that he only obeys at once when commanded, as if Elijah were king and Ahab were the subject and slave. Swift couriers are sent throughout all the kingdom with the summons.12 | The command was issued by one who seemed to stand in the very presence of Jehovah; and Ahab obeyed at once, as if the prophet were monarch, and the king a subject. Swift messengers were sent throughout the kingdom with the summons.13 |
| The prophet had put the king to shame before his people at Carmel, and he ran before his chariot as an act of homage to show that he still acknowledged him as his sovereign.14 | Elijah, who … had that day humiliated Ahab before his subjects … still acknowledged him as Israel's king; and now, as an act of homage … he ran before the royal chariot.15 |
Why did Elijah run before Ahab's chariot to Jezreel? The Bible does not say. March offered an explanation: it was “an act of homage” to show that the prophet still acknowledged his king. Prophets and Kings offers the same explanation in the same words, as if it were inspired insight into the prophet's motive.
The Drought
The copying begins even before Carmel, in the chapters on the drought Elijah announced. March explained why the drought was a fitting judgment: Israel had been taught that the pagan gods controlled nature. So does Prophets and Kings:
| March (1869) | Prophets and Kings (1917) |
|---|---|
| The heathen Jezebel had imported the lascivious rites of Ashtaroth … The people had been taught that these pagan deities ruled the elements of earth and fire and water by their mystic spells. But Elijah still believed that the sun and the clouds … the streams and the fountains were in the hands of Jehovah … when Moses smote the rock … and living waters gushed out.16 | Through the influence of Jezebel and her impious priests, the people were taught that the idol gods that had been set up were deities, ruling by their mystic power the elements of earth, fire, and water. All the bounties of heaven—the running brooks, the streams of living water, the gentle dew, the showers of rain …—were ascribed to the favor of Baal and Ashtoreth.17 |
| The parched earth is all burnt over as with fire. The once fruitful field becomes like ashes … The hot wind drains the moisture from the green leaf … and the suffocating dust-storm sweeps along the hills and highways like the simoon of the desert.18 | The earth is parched as if with fire. The scorching heat of the sun destroys what little vegetation has survived. … Once-flourishing fields have become like burning desert sands … The air is dry and suffocating; dust storms blind the eye.19 |
| The priests of Baal hear of it, and they curse the prophet of Jehovah by all the gods of Tyre and Sidon.20 | Queen Jezebel … lost no time in conferring with the priests of Baal, who united with her in cursing the prophet.21 |
The Burning of the Roll
Rea's list did not include the Jeremiah chapters, but March is there too. When King Jehoiakim cut up Jeremiah's scroll and threw it into the fire, Prophets and Kings pauses for a sermon on how God deals with sinners. The sermon is March's, taken from his reflections on the power of the Word of God:
| March (1869) | Prophets and Kings (1917) |
|---|---|
| It lays heavy burdens upon the conscience, and pierces the soul with the sharp arrows of conviction, and at the same time it offers rest to the weary … that very book which humbles him in the dust.22 | Instead, He lays heavy burdens upon the conscience of the wrongdoer and pierces his soul with sharp arrows of conviction. … But the Hand that humbles to the dust, rebukes sin …23 |
| When one has sinned against a holy and merciful God … there is nothing more just or noble for him to do than to confess and deplore his sin in bitterness of soul.24 | When man has sinned against a holy and merciful God, he can pursue no course so noble as to repent sincerely and confess his errors in tears and bitterness of soul.25 |
These passages are especially telling because of where they sit. The Jeremiah chapters were never serialized in Ellen White's lifetime. They are the chapters Crisler was struggling to build in the fall of 1914, when, as he told W. C. White, the material was “scant” and there was no “more help from Sister White.”26 Whoever placed March's sermon in Jehoiakim's story, the March book was still doing its work in the last years of the project.
Belshazzar's Last Night
March's most dramatic chapter is “The Night Feast of Belshazzar,” and it had the longest life in Ellen White's writings. She first drew on it in an 1881 Review article, again in 1898, and the 1917 book drew on it once more.27
| March (1869) | Ellen White, 1898, and Prophets and Kings (1917) |
|---|---|
| He was admitted to a share in kingly power at fifteen … He lifted himself up against the Lord of heaven.28 | 1898: “Admitted to a share in kingly authority and power at fifteen years of age.” 1917: “Admitted in his youth to a share in kingly authority, Belshazzar gloried in his power and lifted up his heart against the God of heaven.”29 |
| The reckless and the profane not unfrequently display the greatest gayety … when they are on the very brink of destruction. The feeling and the appearance of safety are not always to be taken for reality.30 | In his pride and arrogancy, with a reckless feeling of security Belshazzar “made a great feast to a thousand of his lords.”31 |
| At the very moment when their sacrilegious revelry was at its height, the bodiless hand came forth and wrote the words of doom upon the wall of the banqueting-room, the armies of Cyrus had turned the Euphrates out of its channel and marched into the unguarded city.32 | When the revelry was at its height a bloodless hand came forth and traced upon the walls of the palace characters that gleamed like fire. … The Medes and the Persians, having turned the Euphrates out of its channel, were marching into the heart of the unguarded city.33 |
Notice the fate of March's “at fifteen.” Ellen White copied it in 1898. The 1917 book quietly removed it, leaving the vaguer “in his youth.” And March's “bodiless hand” became her “bloodless hand,” a phrase she had used for decades.
Thirty-Six Years With One Book
Ellen White asked for Night Scenes in the Bible in 1878. She drew on its Belshazzar chapter in 1881 and again in 1898. Its Elijah material appears in the Review articles of 1913. Its reflections on the Word of God appear in the Jeremiah chapters that were assembled in 1914 or later. White mined March for more than thirty years, and then her staff picked up where she left off.
What did March supply? Not facts. March was not a historian. He supplied drama: the secretly plotting priests, the fire like lightning seen from distant rooftops, the king obeying the prophet like a slave, the homage of the run to Jezreel, the reckless revelers at Belshazzar's table. He even supplied the present tense. These are exactly the touches that make Prophets and Kings feel like an eyewitness account, and exactly the touches that SDA readers have taken as proof that Ellen White saw these scenes in vision.
W. C. White explained that his mother used other writers' language to present “those things which she knew through revelation.”34 But the things March supplied are not revealed facts dressed in another writer's words. They are a preacher's imaginative embellishments.
March was not the only Victorian preacher whose Elijah walked into Prophets and Kings. A German court preacher had written a whole book about the Tishbite, and the Elmshaven office had it on the shelf.
References and Notes
- Prophets and Kings, 149–152.
- Daniel March, Night Scenes in the Bible (Philadelphia: Zeigler, McCurdy & Co., 1869), 212.
- Ellen G. White to Mary K. White, Letter 60, 1878, Ellen G. White Estate.
- Warren H. Johns, Tim Poirier, and Ron Graybill, A Bibliography of Ellen G. White's Private and Office Libraries, 3rd rev. ed. (Silver Spring, MD: Ellen G. White Estate, 1993).
- Walter T. Rea, The White Lie (Turlock, CA: M & R Publications, 1982). Further March parallels are collected on the companion page, Ellen White's Plagiarism in Prophets and Kings.
- March, 210–211.
- Prophets and Kings, 149–150.
- March, 211–212.
- Prophets and Kings, 151.
- March, 212.
- Prophets and Kings, 152. Compare 1 Kings 18:38–39.
- March, 208.
- Prophets and Kings, 143.
- March, 213–214.
- Prophets and Kings, 158. Compare 1 Kings 18:46.
- March, 197–198.
- Prophets and Kings, 115.
- March, 206.
- Prophets and Kings, 124. This paragraph also draws on Krummacher's “lowing herds and bleating flocks”; see Chapter 7.
- March, 206.
- Prophets and Kings, 123.
- March, 263.
- Prophets and Kings, 435.
- March, 274.
- Prophets and Kings, 435.
- C. C. Crisler to W. C. White, October 25 and November 5, 1914, correspondence files 036395 and 036406. See Chapter 3.
- Ellen G. White, Review and Herald, February 8, 1881; Bible Echo, April 25, 1898; Youth's Instructor, May 26, 1898. See Chapter 4.
- March, 290.
- Youth's Instructor, May 26, 1898; Prophets and Kings, 522.
- March, 294.
- Prophets and Kings, 523. The phrase “reckless feeling of security” first appears in 1917.
- March, 293.
- Prophets and Kings, 524, 531.
- W. C. White to L. E. Froom, January 8, 1928, in Ellen G. White, Selected Messages, book 3 (Washington, D.C.: Review and Herald Publishing Assn., 1980), 453–461.