The Ellen White Investigation - Online Books

Profits and Kings

Chapter 8 - Memories of Olivet

by Dirk Anderson


Did King Solomon repent? The Bible never says. It reports that his wives turned his heart after other gods, that the Lord was angry with him, and that he died and was buried in the city of David.1 Whether he repented is a question theologians have argued over for two thousand years.

Ellen White answered it twice, and she gave two different answers. In 1864 her account of Solomon, published in Spiritual Gifts, ended with his apostasy and a lament: “Solomon’s heart was turned from God … Had Solomon died prior to his departing from God, his life would have been one of the most remarkable upon record.” He is portrayed as a man who departed from God without any hint of repentance.2 In contrast, by 1917 the same king had become a model penitent: “Solomon's repentance was sincere.”3

Did Ellen White receive a new vision in between these accounts to correct her former vision? Not exactly. The insight came from a book in her library.4 A Scottish minister named John Ross Macduff had suggested that Solomon was, “as we are rather far disposed to think,” “repentant and saved—saved at the eleventh hour.” Macduff was honest enough to admit he could not prove it: “We cannot now go to the proof of this.”5 Prophets and Kings takes his guess and states it as fact.

A Scottish Minister's Meditations

Macduff (1818–1895) was a Church of Scotland minister who served parishes in Forfarshire and Perthshire and then, for fifteen years, Sandyford Church in Glasgow, before retiring to Kent to write full time.6 He was one of the most prolific devotional writers of the Victorian age. His books were warm, pious, and richly pictorial, the kind of reading a Christian family kept by the fireside.

Memories of Olivet (1868) walks the reader around the Mount of Olives, stopping at each scene the mountain had witnessed. Its fourth chapter, “Solomon's High Places on the Mount,” stands on the ruins of the idol shrines Solomon built for his foreign wives and draws the lessons: the reward of sin, the long life of a bad example, a warning to the young, a warning to the old, and a word of hope that even Solomon was saved in the end.

Ellen White did not use it only once. She went back to that one chapter twice, thirty-five years apart.

1870: Two Years Off the Press

In 1870 Ellen White reissued her Old Testament history as the first volume of The Spirit of Prophecy. The Solomon chapter is the 1864 text almost word for word, with one addition. Just before the sentence “Solomon's heart was turned from God,” a new paragraph appears.7 At that time, Macduff's book had been in print for two years.

Macduff, Memories of Olivet (1868)E. White, Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 1 (1870)
Had virtue been the helm of his life, what a freight of glory would that noble vessel have carried, in its course through summer seas. But he recklessly surrendered the helm to passion.8 The life of Solomon might have been remarkable until its close, if virtue had been preserved. But he surrendered this special grace to lustful passion.9
Not who are climbing the mountain—but who are descending, and are facing the westering sun. We often hear of the unsteadiness of giddy youth,—youth wavering between the right and the wrong … and, alas! the current of evil too often proving the strong and the fatal one.10 When he began to descend the declivity of life … he lost his firmness of character and became more like the giddy youth, wavering between right and wrong. Yielding his principles, he placed himself in the current of evil.11
Though patrimonied with the gold of Ophir, the silver-mines of Tarshish …12 Wisdom had been more precious to him than the gold of Ophir.13
What a lesson for watchfulness! What a testimony as to the need of grace to the very last, in the battle with inward corruption and outward temptation!14 What a lesson for watchfulness! What a testimony as to the need of strength from God to the very last! In the battle with inward corruptions and outward temptations, even the wise and powerful Solomon was vanquished.15

Two exclamations, word for word, and a third clause with only “grace” swapped for “strength from God.” This was not a secretary's work in Ellen White's old age. In 1870 she was forty-two, writing at full strength, and the paragraph went out under her name in a book labeled Spirit of Prophecy that SDAs were taught to receive as the fruit of her visions.

Notice also what she did not take. Four pages before his warning to the aged, Macduff had offered his hope that Solomon was saved. In 1870 she left that out and kept her 1864 ending. Perhaps she thought the contradiction would be too obvious. Whatever the reason, Solomon's rescue would have to wait another thirty-six years.

1905: Back to the Mount

In August 1905 the Review and Herald began a twenty-three-part series under Ellen White's name, “Lessons From the Life of Solomon.” It ran until February 1906 and became the backbone of the first five chapters of Prophets and Kings. The series was not written the way SDAs imagine. In July 1905 W. W. Prescott, editor of the Review, mentioned “the forth-coming series of articles for the Review on the Life of Solomon, which I understand he [Crisler] has edited for your mother.”16

Whether White wrote the articles or Crisler, one fact is certain: Macduff's chapter was on the editor's desk again. This time almost all of it was used.

Macduff, Memories of Olivet (1868)Prophets and Kings (1917)
His name “Jedidiah,” “the beloved of God” … his life—and that, too, not only after a morning, but a manhood, of promise—was a history of deterioration.17 But after a morning of great promise his life was darkened by apostasy. History records the melancholy fact that he who had been called Jedidiah,—“Beloved of the Lord” … turned from the worship of Jehovah.18
A pile of imposing buildings of Tyrian architecture, crowned the southern eminence of the Mount of Olives. Gigantic idols,—some, unshapely blocks of wood, others of stone … peered above the groves of myrtle, olive, and terebinth.19 On the southern eminence of the Mount of Olives, opposite Mount Moriah … Solomon erected an imposing pile of buildings to be used as idolatrous shrines. To please his wives, he placed huge idols, unshapely images of wood and stone, amidst the groves of myrtle and olive.20
The political alliances with adjoining Pagan kingdoms … The extension of commercial intercourse … The silver of Tarshish and the gold of Ophir were procured at the expense of tarnishing nobler traditions. … His extravagance was maintained at the expense of a grinding taxation.21 The king's alliances and commercial relations with heathen nations brought him renown … He was enabled to bring gold from Ophir and silver from Tarshish in great abundance. … The enormous revenues acquired through commerce with many lands were supplemented by heavy taxes.22
A character, originally bold and independent, became enervated and effeminate,—the tool and slave of others. His fine sensibilities were blunted,—his conscience seared. The lauded justice and magnanimity of his early reign was changed into tyranny. … He who had prayed for his people at the dedication of the Temple, ‘Let your hearts be undividedly given unto the Lord,’ now himself began to divide his heart.” … He tried to incorporate light with darkness, Christ with Belial, purity with impurity, good with evil. … Poor frail human nature!23 His fine sensibilities became blunted, his conscience seared. … He who at the dedication of the temple had said to his people, “Let your heart therefore be perfect with the Lord our God,” became himself an offender … He tried—but at what cost!—to unite light with darkness, good with evil, purity with impurity, Christ with Belial. … Solomon became a profligate, the tool and slave of others. His character, once noble and manly, became enervated and effeminate. … The justice and magnanimity of his early reign were changed to despotism and tyranny. Poor, frail human nature!24
The life and example of Solomon has a special moral and warning also to the aged:—to those—not who are climbing the mountain—but who are descending, and are facing the westering sun. We often hear of the unsteadiness of giddy youth,—youth wavering between the right and the wrong … and, alas! the current of evil too often proving the strong and the fatal one. But we seldom think of unsteadiness and vacillation in connexion with maturer years: we generally suppose that … character is stereotyped, principles rooted … Generally, it is so: but not always. … An old gnarled cedar of Lebanon, a sturdy oak of Bashan bent before the blast of temptation.25 Not only to the youth, but to those of mature years, and to those who are descending the hill of life and facing the western sun, the life of Solomon is full of warning. We see and hear of unsteadiness in youth, the young wavering between right and wrong, and the current of evil passions proving too strong for them. In those of maturer years, we do not look for this unsteadiness and unfaithfulness; we expect the character to be established, the principles firmly rooted. But this is not always so. When Solomon should have been in character as a sturdy oak, he fell from his steadfastness under the power of temptation.26

The fourth row is the most brazen. Macduff's paragraph on Solomon's decline is taken nearly whole and shuffled. It even keeps Macduff's sigh, “Poor frail human nature!” Rearranging the order did not make the words hers.

The 1905–06 series was more brazen still. On February 15, 1906, the Review described the shrines “crowning the eminence of the Mount of Olives, and peering above the groves of myrtle and olive trees,” with their “gigantic” idols, and reported that “many of the broken fragments rolled down the channel of the Kedron.” Macduff: “Gigantic idols … peered above the groves of myrtle, olive”; “broken in fragments, and rolled down to the channel of the Kedron.”27 Those phrases—the “gigantic” idols “peering above” the groves and the fragments rolling down the Kedron—never reached Prophets and Kings. Someone trimmed the most recognizable phrases before the book went to press.

Saved at the Eleventh Hour

On February 8, 1906, the series reached Solomon's last years under the title “Godly Sorrow Worketh Repentance.”28 For the first time in forty-two years of writing about him, Ellen White's Solomon repents. The king who in 1864 and 1870 simply fell now turns back, writes Ecclesiastes as a penitent, and dies forgiven. Every element of the new ending is in Macduff.

Macduff, Memories of Olivet (1868)Prophets and Kings (1917)
Go and read another of his sacred writings … the Book of Ecclesiastes. That book, may we not fondly hope, was composed in the last hours of penitent life. It is a mournful autobiography—a mournful retrospective diary.29 In penitence he began to retrace his steps … By the spirit of inspiration the king recorded for after generations the history of his wasted years with their lessons of warning.30
Repentant and saved—saved at the eleventh hour … His penitence may have been (and we charitably trust was) sincere. … His repentance could not demolish these stone memorials, nor obliterate the memory of his great crimes. … He had transmitted a legacy of foul example, to those who would not fail to screen and cover their own infamy by his greatness.31 Solomon's repentance was sincere; but the harm that his example of evil-doing had wrought could not be undone. … Though the king confessed his sin and wrote out for the benefit of after generations a record of his folly and repentance, he could never hope entirely to destroy the baleful influence of his wrong deeds. Emboldened by his apostasy, many continued to do evil.32

Macduff hedges at every step: “may we not fondly hope,” “we charitably trust,” “as we are rather far disposed to think,” “we cannot now go to the proof of this.” He knows he is guessing, and he says so. Prophets and Kings removes every hedge. Macduff's charitable trust becomes a flat declaration, “Solomon's repentance was sincere,” and his fond hope about Ecclesiastes becomes something the king wrote “by the spirit of inspiration.”

That is the heart of the matter. A Scottish minister's opinion, offered humbly and labeled as opinion, was taken without credit, stripped of its qualifications, and handed to SDAs as the verdict of a prophet. Worse yet, it overturned what the same prophet had published twice before. If the 1864 Solomon came from God, the 1917 Solomon came from Macduff.

Inward Corruption, Inward Sin

One sentence from Macduff's chapter can be followed across half a century, and its small changes show the handling it received.

VersionText
Macduff, 1868What a testimony as to the need of grace to the very last, in the battle with inward corruption and outward temptation!33
Spirit of Prophecy, 1870In the battle with inward corruptions and outward temptations, even the wise and powerful Solomon was vanquished.34
Review, 1906In the battle with inward corruptions and outward temptations …35
Prophets and Kings, 1917In the battle with inward sin and outward temptation, even the wise and powerful Solomon was vanquished.36

For forty-nine years the sentence kept Macduff's word, “corruption.” Then, in the book finished by her staff, it became “inward sin.” Someone at Elmshaven read Macduff's sentence closely enough to edit his vocabulary, and still printed it under her name without a word of credit.

Forty-Nine Years With One Chapter

Consider the sequence. Macduff published in 1868. Ellen White lifted his warning to the aged in 1870. Her office, with Crisler editing, mined the rest of his Solomon chapter in 1905 and 1906: the shrines on the southern eminence, the seared conscience, Christ with Belial, the western sun, the sturdy oak, and the repentance he only hoped for. In 1917 her staff trimmed the most obvious lines, changed his “corruptions” to “sin,” and published the result as Prophets and Kings.

Three generations of SDAs read those words as a prophet's inside view of Solomon's heart without realizing they were reading a Victorian devotional book. Why would they suspect otherwise? The words were copied first by Ellen White and then by her assistants, over nearly half a century, without a word of credit.

Macduff was not the only British preacher on her shelf. A London minister's lectures on Daniel had been feeding her ravenous pen for decades.

References and Notes

  1. 1 Kings 11:4–11, 43.
  2. Ellen G. White, Spiritual Gifts, vol. 4a (Battle Creek, MI: Steam Press of the Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association, 1864), 100.
  3. Prophets and Kings, 84.
  4. Warren H. Johns, Tim Poirier, and Ron Graybill, A Bibliography of Ellen G. White's Private and Office Libraries, 3rd rev. ed. (Silver Spring, MD: Ellen G. White Estate, 1993), entry for Macduff, Memories of Olivet (New York: R. Carter and Bros., 1868), codes A, B, C, “3 copies.” Page numbers here follow the London edition of the same year. The inventory of her estate records three copies, in her private library, in the office library, and among the books Crisler sold to her in 1913.
  5. J. R. Macduff, Memories of Olivet (London: James Nisbet & Co., 1868), 77, 82. Hereafter “Macduff.”
  6. “John Ross Macduff,” Wikipedia, accessed October 22, 2026.
  7. Ellen G. White, The Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 1 (Battle Creek, MI: Steam Press of the Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association, 1870), chap. 35, “Solomon,” 287–292. The added paragraph is reprinted in Counsels on Health, 582–583.
  8. Macduff, 81.
  9. Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 1 (1870); Counsels on Health, 582.
  10. Macduff, 81.
  11. Counsels on Health, 582.
  12. Macduff, 75.
  13. Counsels on Health, 582.
  14. Macduff, 82.
  15. Counsels on Health, 582.
  16. W. W. Prescott to W. C. White, July 13, 1905, Ellen G. White Estate correspondence file 041437.
  17. Macduff, 71–72.
  18. Prophets and Kings, 50; first printed in the Review and Herald, October 19, 1905.
  19. Macduff, 70.
  20. Prophets and Kings, 57.
  21. Macduff, 72–73.
  22. Prophets and Kings, 54–55. The 1905 version is closer still: “the silver of Tarshish and the gold of Ophir were procured at a terrible expense” (Review and Herald, August 17, 1905).
  23. Macduff, 73–74.
  24. Prophets and Kings, 57–58; first printed in the Review and Herald, December 21, 1905.
  25. Macduff, 81–82.
  26. Prophets and Kings, 82; first printed in the Review and Herald, February 22, 1906.
  27. “Lessons From the Life of Solomon,” Review and Herald, February 15, 1906; Macduff, 70.
  28. “Lessons From the Life of Solomon: Godly Sorrow Worketh Repentance,” Review and Herald, February 8, 1906.
  29. Macduff, 79.
  30. Prophets and Kings, 78–79.
  31. Macduff, 77.
  32. Prophets and Kings, 84.
  33. Macduff, 82.
  34. Spirit of Prophecy, vol. 1 (1870); Counsels on Health, 582.
  35. “Lessons From the Life of Solomon,” Review and Herald, February 22, 1906.
  36. Prophets and Kings, 82.